Why do the smartest people do the dumbest things?
I turn 51 on Monday (thanks in advance for the well-wishes and generous gifts), and I’ve been “the boss” of one company or another, nonstop, since I was 24. Even if Tara and I hadn’t started dating when I was 22, workplace power dynamics forever disqualified me from office romance. Of the countless difficult challenges and decisions that come with running a company, not having an extramarital affair with a colleague might literally be the easiest one.
It’s not that I haven’t done plenty of other stupid things as a CEO. Dropping everyone but clients and friends from this email list a couple years ago was a particularly dumb decision. Initially launching our advertising business under a completely separate brand was another. I’ve sent sensitive emails to the wrong recipients and spoke in front of the whole company once with my fly down. I missed a flight a couple weeks ago while sitting in the boarding area on a phone call. I make mistakes, large and small, every day. I just try to not make the same one twice.
I’ve done 10 times more boneheaded things at home. Preoccupation with work can render me less present than I should be. I don’t think about how my travels and activities affect Tara often enough. I call my kids by the wrong names. I forget to take out the trash and put the toilet seat down. Unfortunately, I’ve done each of those things more times than I can count.
Because of that, I’m also slow to judge — or to idolize. People are inherently imperfect. We never know their personal circumstances. The most honorable people have horrible lapses in judgment, while the most loathsome ones can have extraordinary moments of virtue.
But it certainly seems like the people we place on the highest pedestals are the ones prone to the most epic fails. Maybe it’s because reaching superhuman levels of achievement require degrees of obsession and self-centeredness that inevitably manifest in uglier ways. Maybe if you spend your life so singularly focused on your field or job, you don’t develop the emotional tools necessary to fend off your worst impulses.
I’m not a psychologist, so I don’t know.
But I do wonder whether we should be putting anyone — least of all, the wealthiest and most powerful among us — on those kinds of pedestals in the first place.
Here’s what we’re seeing:
We got much happier all of the sudden. You’ll recall from my write-up a few weeks ago that, by the end of September, American happiness was the lowest it had ever been in 14 years of tracking it. What a difference an election makes. Not only have those numbers rebounded, but we are now collectively happier than we’ve been since lockdown ended in 2021. It’s also the highest we’ve ever seen in the month of November and the biggest jump between a pre- and post-election period. Millennials saw the largest gains, although happiness increased by at least five points among every age group. Yay!

Post-election giddiness may not lead to jollier holiday retail spending. Delving further into the midterm reverberations, we wanted to see if consumer spending might be affected in the immediate aftermath. Even as 54% of U.S. adults say the midterm results made them more ‘optimistic,’ the second-largest group was merely ‘relieved.’ All told, not only are people not planning to spend more following the election, a plurality say they’re now planning to spend less. The one exception is the Hispanic population, the balance of whom are now more likely to increase their outlays for health & wellness, investing, and apparel. P.S. — Nobody is better at reaching these Hispanic spenders than we are.

Even before Election Day, America’s personal financial outlook was on an upswing. Our Consumer Financial Health Index improved in October, following two months of declines. It’s a good time to remind you that the CFHI is a forward-looking indicator, which tells us people were already expecting change in the weeks before the midterms. Four of the five key metrics improved in the latest reading, with the biggest gains on credit, income, and investment optimism. The one downer was the personal debt metric — people expect their IOUs to deepen in the coming months.

Younger adults are turning to urgent care centers to manage their health care costs. In our 3 Things to Know this week, we found that a larger share of Gen Zs and Millennials (particularly Millennial parents) are leaning hard into the convenience and cost-effectiveness of urgent care facilities for their medical needs. The largest shares are those who are self-insured or on government assistance programs and live in urban areas. In other news, we learned that intent to buy gift cards this holiday season is way up, and a lot of people bought discounted candy after Halloween.

Big-box retailers could see a big boost in holiday shopping this year. With Black Friday just two weeks away, we’re dialing up our look at holiday retail trends. Among the notable findings is that a growing percentage of shoppers expect to buy from box stores like Walmart or Target, in-person and online, while the percentage who plan to patronize online-only retailers like Amazon is down from last year. I have a crazy theory that AI (and Amazon’s refusal to allow AI search of its products) has something to do with that. We also showed that while toy-buying intent across categories is falling this year, plush toys and dress-up are two bright spots.

More awesomeness from the InsightStore™:
- In some freebie insights from our Agentic Retail Tracker, we shared data on how shopping categories vary significantly among users of different AI tools — and even more significantly when further cut by gender.
The most popular questions this week:
Do you feel ready for the arrival of the holiday season?
How favorable or unfavorable of an opinion do you have about the 4-day school week?
Have you ever seen a bald eagle in the wild?
Would you ever stay at a hotel that’s known to be haunted?
How do you typically deal with spiders in your home?
Answer Key: I can’t effing wait; Stupid idea; I saw two perched on the same rock behind our cabin last week; No place is “known to be haunted;” Tara makes me kill them.
Hoping you’re well.
JD